Sarah McBride Is Used to the Hate

Subscribe right here: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Overcast | Pocket Casts

If this weren’t the 119th Congress she’d simply joined, Consultant Sarah McBride of Delaware is likely to be having the most effective yr of her life. Rising up, she centered on Washington with close to Tracy Flick depth. She constructed White Home fashions in her childhood bed room, interned for Beau Biden, and was elected president of the American College pupil physique. When she got here out as trans in her final yr at AU, McBride figured her political profession would get stunted. However she instantly landed an internship on the Obama White Home, acquired elected to state Senate, after which on to Congress, all earlier than turning 30. Dream achieved—besides that she occurred to land in a congressional class with members intent on making an instance of her.

Earlier than McBride arrived, Consultant Nancy Mace of South Carolina launched a invoice that will forbid transgender girls from utilizing girls’s restrooms within the U.S. Capitol. At McBride’s first listening to, Consultant Keith Self of Texas launched her as Mr. McBride. McBride shouldn’t be new to harassment. She’s been badgered just about always since turning into an elected official. However getting trolled within the halls of Congress whereas attempting to take care of her composure and get her job carried out is a brand new problem.

On this episode of Radio Atlantic, we speak with Sarah McBride about how she navigates Congress, personally and politically, and the way she thinks Democrats ought to navigate the culture-wars minefields.

The next is a transcript of the episode:

Hanna Rosin: In November, two weeks after Consultant Sarah McBride of Delaware grew to become the primary trans member of Congress, Consultant Nancy Mace of South Carolina launched a invoice that will forbid transgender girls from utilizing feminine restrooms within the U.S. Capitol, which was McBride’s new office.

And when requested if this was in direct response to McBride’s win, Mace responded with, quote: “Sure, and completely after which some.”

Rosin: Then final month, in March, at a Home listening to—

Rosin: Consultant Keith Self of Texas launched McBride by misgendering her, to which she replied:

McBride: That’s the greatest takeaway for me—one of many greatest takeaways for me—is how a lot Congress is, sadly, a reality-TV present.

Rosin: (Laughs.) That means that it’s performative?

McBride: Mm-hmm. And that means that the aim of the day is to get airtime. And with a view to get airtime, the simplest manner is to make use of the methods of parents on Bravo TV exhibits, the place to get airtime, you decide an individual, decide a combat with them, throw wine of their face, and that will get airtime. And that’s not solely the technique however actually the defining function of what’s a win versus a loss for lots of Republican members of Congress.

[Music]

Rosin: That is Radio Atlantic. I’m Hanna Rosin.

Sarah McBride was making fashions of the White Home in her room when she was 6 years outdated. Her large birthday want, as a Delaware child, was to fulfill Joe Biden. (She did, by the best way, and he later ended up writing the foreword to her memoir.)

When McBride got here out as trans in school, she frightened that it will kill her political goals. Nevertheless it didn’t. She grew to become the primary trans speaker on the 2016 Democratic Nationwide Conference. She was elected state senator in 2020, then elected to Congress in 2024, at exactly the second when trans points grew to become a singular fixation for her opposing social gathering.

On President Trump’s first day, in his inaugural speech, he proclaimed that the federal government would now not actually acknowledge trans individuals.

Rosin: Trump has signed government orders that will ban transgender individuals from serving within the army, defund gender-affirming look after trans youth, block funding for faculties that promote concepts of gender fluidity or transitioning. And simply yesterday, the Trump administration introduced that it was suing Maine for not complying with its push to ban transgender athletes in women’ sports activities.

So right here is Sarah McBride, residing her childhood dream on the most inconvenient second. And I wished to know what that have was like.

McBride: So I all the time knew, after I determined to run for this seat, that there could be some members of Congress who would use my service to attain political factors and acquire consideration. And I all the time knew that that would come with misgendering.

Rosin: You probably did?

McBride: I simply assumed that the performative nature of federal politics would end in individuals misgendering me. And one of many issues I stated to individuals in the course of the course of the marketing campaign is, They’re gonna strive to do that, and my job goes to be to not give them the response that they need. And I am going in each day centered on my job, centered on serving Delaware, centered on introducing now two and shortly to be three bipartisan payments. However I additionally go in recognizing that at any second, a member might resolve to make use of my presence in an area to realize consideration.

It doesn’t really feel good when it occurs. And the primary time it occurred was on the ground in my first ground speech. There had been some indicators; individuals had type of talked amongst themselves that it most likely wouldn’t occur.

Rosin: What do you imply? You imply your allies had, in a comforting manner? Or—

McBride: Yeah. I believe there had been possibly some conversations amongst some workers.

Rosin: Okay.

McBride: And the tea leaves, they thought, instructed that it wouldn’t occur. So when it did occur the primary time on the ground—

McBride: —after I was launched as “the gentleman from Delaware, Mr. McBride”—

McBride: I’ve been deliberately misgendered. Earlier than I got here to Congress, I wasn’t getting misgendered just about ever. And sometimes, I’d get misgendered deliberately, somebody attempting to attain factors. You recognize, I’d be in a parade, and somebody would yell one thing out. That doesn’t trouble me. I do know they’re doing it in a manner that’s crude, however it’s not information to me that I’m trans, proper? I’m happy with who I’m. That’s not an issue. I didn’t assume it will be type of emotionally heavy for me.

It’s a completely different factor when it’s coming from the dais of america Home of Representatives, proper? It’s a completely different factor when it’s within the congressional document. And that does harm greater than it will usually. I believe, for me, in that second, what harm on the ground was: I might see individuals within the gallery snickering. And I’m an individual, proper? That is the primary time I’m on the ground of the Home of Representatives. I’m nervous to ship my first ground speech. And so I simply went into my speech and delivered it.

Within the occasion in committee the place I did reply by saying, “Madam Chair,” to a person who was presiding—

Rosin: That was good. I used to be questioning, did she have that in her head already ready, or did that simply come spontaneously once you known as him, “Madam Chair”? As a result of that was fairly good.

McBride: Properly, I in truth regretted saying, “Madam Chair,” proper after I stated it.

Rosin: Did you?

McBride: I went again to my workplace and was not pleased with myself. It’s simply not my model. I’m actually right here to give attention to the job and to be critical. And you’ll have humor, and typically it’s proper to simply type of reply in type, however I don’t assume I fulfill my obligations to anybody, whether or not that’s Delawareans or some other group I’m part of, by constantly sinking to their degree.

Rosin: It’s loads of stress. It instantly popped into my thoughts: Jackie Robinson, tour of the South, type of having to play—I imply, it’s loads of stress, I believe, so that you can be good. Look good, be good, act good, do every thing completely. It looks as if possibly that’s the stress on a first, and also you in some way acknowledge that, otherwise you’re a naturally diplomatic individual. I’m undecided, however—

McBride: I believe that there isn’t a query that there are added obligations, there’s added stress to a primary. I’d by no means examine myself to Jackie Robinson, however one factor, after I began, individuals beneficial I watch 42. And there’s a actually highly effective scene within the begin, the place the proprietor of the Dodgers says to Jackie Robinson, For those who reply to a slur with a slur, they’ll solely hear yours. For those who reply to a punch with a punch, they’ll say you’re the aggressor.

Rosin: Proper.

McBride: And I believe that that’s an apt description of the problem that, actually, most marginalized individuals face when coming into a office. You recognize, on the finish of the day, the best way I strive to consider it, although, is: The one manner that I can assure that, whereas I could also be a primary, I’m not the final, is to simply fairly merely be the most effective member of Congress that I could be and to do the nuts and bolts of the job to the most effective of my capability.

I’ll make errors. There’ll be occasions the place I ought to reply to issues, and there are occasions the place I shouldn’t reply to issues that I received’t strike the suitable stability. I’m going to make errors, and I believe giving myself the identical grace that I’m keen to increase to different individuals in navigating what’s a fairly unprecedented state of affairs, the place, you already know, I’ve tried to take a look at different examples to be taught from, and I haven’t been capable of finding somebody who has entered Congress as a primary when the identification that makes them a primary is on the heart of political debate and the district that they symbolize isn’t considerably or predominantly made up of that identification.

Rosin: Proper? It is vitally uncommon. You’re coming into Congress at a time when trans persons are at their most seen and their most susceptible. These two issues are concurrently true, and in order that creates a most stress cooker.

It appears from realizing your biographies, for some time, every thing went effectively. Like, the containers have been getting checked. You got here out: American College, individuals have been supportive; 2013, you’ve gotten an enormous position within the Gender Id and Nondiscrimination Act in Delaware. There was a way that we have been at Trans 101, America was at Trans 101. We have been simply studying the language, understanding what transgender was. Plenty of a lot youthful youngsters, my very own included, had loads of expertise with transgender pals and that we might transfer alongside to the graduate research. After which it didn’t—effectively, do you continue to assume that? I imply, do you continue to assume it’s marching ahead in that manner?

McBride: I believe we’re experiencing a major second of regression culturally on this nation on all problems with gender. Public opinion is worse now than it was on nearly each concern than it was 5 years in the past. And—

Rosin: That means what? Like, to what questions, for instance?

McBride: Virtually each conceivable query.

Rosin: Like transgender rights?

McBride: There are nonetheless trans-rights points which have majority help, however each single ballot I’ve seen exhibits much less help now than there was 5 or 6 years in the past—on just about each concern. From nondiscrimination protections, which nonetheless keep majority help, to army participation, which nonetheless maintains majority help, to different points that both don’t have, by no means have had, or now don’t have majority help.

And I believe that there are a few causes for that. One, it’s a sustained right-wing disinformation, misinformation, and fearmongering marketing campaign that has an impact. And I believe one of many issues that individuals would say in 2015, 2016 to me is, Oh my goodness. It seems like we’re shifting so shortly on trans rights, in a great way, proper? And we’d reward it. And my motive for that was, I believe I stated on the time, and I nonetheless assume that is true: I believe there’s type of a switch of momentum from the LGB to the T, from marriage equality to trans rights, the place individuals in 2015, 2016, proper after marriage equality grew to become the legislation of the land, they went, You recognize, I keep in mind being unsuitable on marriage. And so there was that lesson of: Simply since you don’t perceive one thing doesn’t imply that you just received’t finally help it.

And so they form of took that lesson and transferred it, on the time, to trans rights. And I believe what it did was, it created a false sense of safety. It created a dynamic the place public opinion was type of a mile extensive however an inch deep. It was type of a home constructed on sand in some methods. I believe that due to that, we maybe, as a group, didn’t do sufficient public schooling to construct the muse that the gay-rights a part of the motion had constructed once they acquired to 2010, 2012, 2014 with progress on the difficulty of marriage—the place that public help was rooted in a data basis, an understanding of who homosexual individuals have been. And I don’t assume that that basis existed, or to today exists, for trans individuals.

Rosin: It’s fascinating as a result of that’s additionally in regards to the velocity of knowledge. I imply, the best way details about homosexual individuals and homosexual rights occurred was at a a lot slower tempo, like Will & Grace, by means of tv. It simply form of occurred on this ambient manner, and that’s not how info strikes anymore.

I imply, I’m considering of you in 2016, which is only some years after that Delaware invoice was handed, had that viral submit the place you wrote: “I’m only a individual. We’re all simply individuals. Attempting to pee in peace,” once you took that selfie from the North Carolina lavatory. However I really feel such as you discovered a lesson. That was possibly the primary time that you just discovered—or possibly not the primary time, however that you just discovered one thing from that that may inform what you’re saying now. What occurred after that?

McBride: I imply, the torrent of hate that got here in after that was actually scary and traumatizing for me. And after that have, first off—

Rosin: Greater than you anticipated?

McBride: Rather more. I simply had by no means skilled that degree of hate. Now it’s primarily an on a regular basis incidence, however—

Rosin: Actually?

McBride: I imply, on-line it’s fairly incessant.

Rosin: To what, although? Like, any time you’ve gotten an image or your, like, X account?

McBride: Oh, something I do.

Rosin: Something.

McBride: I stated the opposite week, I reside hire free in some people’ heads, and it’s—I’ll say stuff that has nothing to do with me, and actually simply saying it is going to end in a torrent of anti-trans commentary. Nevertheless it doesn’t trouble me anymore, due to that have that I had then, the place I noticed—so I acquired this hate, together with lots of people telling me I ought to kill myself.

Rosin: Yeah. What was the phrase? It’s “KYS.”

McBride: “KYS. KYS, KYS, KYS.” And I by no means would’ve anticipated that individuals telling me that I ought to do that will ever really impression me. However at a sure level, the amount and velocity of it grew to become a lot that I couldn’t assist however really feel it. And I keep in mind after this, I keep in mind considering, I don’t know that I can do that, do that work.

And I went on this type of info journey to grasp the psychology and bullying of trolling. And I got here throughout a This American Life episode that actually simply allowed issues to click on for me. It was Lindy West who wrote about her physique and her weight lots. And he or she would get trolled. After which she wrote about how a lot that trolling harm her, and the troll reached out and apologized.

Rosin: Oh. Was this the episode the place they really talked to the troll?

McBride: Sure.

Rosin: And I’ll do not forget that episode perpetually as a result of they talked to the troll, and it was very bizarre, that episode. The troll was like, Yeah. I don’t know. No biggie. I used to be simply doing my factor.

McBride: No biggie. I used to be simply doing my factor. And he acknowledged that he was struggling together with his personal weight.

Rosin: Mm-hmm.

McBride: There’s the outdated cliche that the largest closet circumstances are the largest bullies. And in some circumstances, that’s true, however it underestimates a bigger, extra common reality, which is that everybody has an insecurity. And the factor about LGBTQ individuals is that if we’re out, we’ve got taken that insecurity, that concern, that factor that society has informed us we ought to be ashamed of, and we’ve got not solely accepted it however in lots of circumstances walked ahead from a spot of satisfaction in it. And the bullies see that energy—they see that particular person company and conquering our personal concern—they usually’re jealous of it.

And so after I see the issues that individuals say about me writ massive, the MAGA motion writ massive, to me, I simply assume, I hope they discover therapeutic. And in truth, one of many the reason why I do that work is as a result of I believe on this nation, we so desperately want politicians who acknowledge that they don’t must consider that persons are proper for what persons are dealing with to be unsuitable. And we don’t must consider that persons are proper for us to attempt to proper that unsuitable. And I wish to combat for individuals who appear like me and assume like me, and individuals who don’t appear like me and don’t assume like me and would possibly even be saying actually, actually, actually hurtful issues about me, as a result of we are going to all be higher off if all of us heal a little bit bit.

Rosin:  I’m attempting to resolve in my head in case you’re attempting to persuade your self. I imply, that’s a really beneficiant place, and I’m positive it prices you some. It’s a type of generosity from on excessive, you already know? I imply, possibly you’re all the best way there. I don’t know. It’s a extremely arduous place to embody.

McBride: There are occasions the place I battle with it. However one, I really consider it, and it, frankly, makes it simpler for me to cope with issues to know that when persons are saying these issues, it’s saying extra about them than it’s about me. And I don’t consider what they’re saying, so then I can type of dispassionately take away myself from it and look and simply say, What you are saying, Yeah, it’s not good to me or individuals like me—

Rosin: Nevertheless it’s about you.

McBride: —however it isn’t about me. I do assume for some people, the cruelty could be the purpose, however I do consider that harm individuals, harm individuals. And I do consider, sure, we’ve type of gone down this rabbit gap of disinformation and misinformation, and it radicalizes individuals. However I believe persons are a lot extra inclined to being radicalized when they’re harm and in ache and in concern.

[Music]

Rosin: After the break: what occurs to idealism when the vibes are dangerous, and the way Sarah McBride thinks the Democrats can take again energy.

[Break]

Rosin: So Trump’s government order about there being solely two organic sexes—have you ever developed any theories about why that’s so necessary?

McBride: I imply, I attempt to—look: I don’t actually assume Donald Trump cares about these items. Donald Trump cares about what will get him extra energy and what will get him extra money. I don’t assume Donald Trump cares about trans individuals or LGBTQ individuals. I believe individuals in his orbit do. I believe he sees that some individuals in his base do.

It’s most likely a part of a authorized technique to put the muse to, clearly, not solely remove the conception of nonbinary people in legislation however to create a definition that lays the muse for the federal government now not validating or acknowledging or respecting binary trans identities.

Rosin: You’ve talked about on this dialog hope. You’ve given a imaginative and prescient, which is extraordinarily idealistic, significantly for somebody your age. Generally, although,

I imply, the vibes are off proper now.

McBride: Sure. The vibes are dangerous.

Rosin: (Laughs.) The vibes are dangerous. You’ve additionally stated that—how do you maintain these two issues directly? Like, as soon as once more, you already know, in case you take a look at you in 2013, issues have been wanting like they have been shifting in a sure path. You your self have stated they’ve form of veered completely backwards, so how do you make sense of that bigger historic arc and discover your idealism in it?

McBride: Look—there are loads of causes proper now to not be optimistic.

Rosin: Mm-hmm.

McBride: However, you already know, I believe we regularly consider historical past and humanity as cumulative. We really feel like we’re the beneficiary of lots of of years of classes of historical past. However the actuality is that until you’ve gotten lived it and skilled it, it’s fairly straightforward to not comprehend it. You recognize, my era, we grew up; we have been born after the autumn of the Soviet Union, proper? We’ve existed in a world submit–civil rights, post-Sixties. And one of many issues that I take consolation in, on this second, having tried to take time to pay attention and find out about what it felt wish to reside within the occasions previous to the Sixties, is that the sense of inevitability that with arduous work, change will come, that we’ve got felt in a post-Sixties world the sense that we have been on this type of never-ending cresting wave of cultural momentum—that’s all of the exception in our historical past, proper?

Sure, we’ve got each motive to concern that change received’t come proper now, however you possibly can’t inform me that the explanations for hopelessness now are higher than the explanations for hopelessness for an LGBTQ individual in 1965, earlier than Stonewall, once they possibly by no means knew of a actuality the place they may reside overtly and authentically as themselves with out violating the legislation. Each earlier era, particularly these generations previous to the ’60s and ’70s, confronted seemingly not possible odds. They may not see the sunshine on the finish of the tunnel. But they persevered. They summoned their hope, they discovered the sunshine, they usually modified the world.

Rosin: Proper. I believe what you’re saying is, like, a zoom in, zoom out.

It’s like, how broadly do you wish to see—like, the polls you talked about possibly belong to the extra slender realm of optimism, however then you possibly can put your self within the broader religious, bigger historic arc of hope, which is a special time span.

I wish to drag you, although, again into this time span.

McBride: Sure.

Rosin: So we’ve got 4 years forward of us. There’s loads of laws. What are you monitoring and watching? What are you taking a look at, and what are you frightened about within the laws?

McBride: I’m wanting, frankly, past—I’m taking a look at every thing. As a result of we’ve gotta acknowledge that every one of those assaults are interconnected. I’m wanting on the cash that’s being stolen proper now from farmers, from well being officers, from federally certified well being facilities, from meals banks, from infrastructure funds in Delaware and throughout the nation by the federal authorities. I’m wanting on the effort to implement the most important lower in American historical past of Medicaid. I’m wanting on the federal staff who’re being summarily fired in Delaware and throughout the nation as a result of this administration is attempting to grind authorities to a halt.

All of that comes collectively to attempt to create a world the place individuals proceed to be hungry and scared and fearful, which then lays the muse for these fears and that insecurity to be exploited, to remove due course of for each undocumented immigrants and authorized immigrants on this nation, authorized residents, for them to focus on and scapegoat and concern monger round trans individuals. All of that is interconnected, and I don’t assume that we are able to single out considered one of these areas. I definitely don’t have the posh of doing that as a member of Congress.

Rosin: And so regardless that a few of these points are actual issues Republicans care about, and a few, as you stated, are performative and issues they possibly don’t care a lot about, is your intuition the Democrats must focus extra on the issues they actually care about, like, say, the shrinking of presidency versus the performative, you already know, as you began out saying, Actual Housewives-y sorts of issues?

McBride: Properly, I believe there are two completely different worlds there. I believe there’s their performative fights which might be offensive, however the harm is extra slender. Then there’s issues that they don’t care about that they’re doing that harm lots of people. I don’t assume Donald Trump himself cares about trans individuals, however he’s hurting trans individuals.

I do assume Donald Trump cares about hurting immigrants. I believe he desires to harm immigrants, as a result of I believe Donald Trump—the by means of line of his whole political philosophy for 40 years has been anti-immigration. However I believe these are two various things: issues he doesn’t care about which have widespread hurt, and issues that he doesn’t care about that’s performative, that’s nearly rallying up the bottom and the place the hurt is extra restricted.

I believe, clearly, we ought to be pushing again towards the efforts to sanction or mandate discrimination towards trans individuals writ massive on this nation. We ought to be combating again towards efforts to insert authorities between sufferers, suppliers, and households. We ought to be defending trans service members who’re serving this nation.

And in all of that, we should always acknowledge that a very powerful factor for anybody who’s being focused by this administration is for us to gradual this administration down. And sadly, due to the outcomes of the final election, the primary lever at our disposal is public opinion. We do have to acknowledge that we’ve got to combat arduous and combat good, which implies combating and specializing in the problems the place the general public is with us, and due to this fact we are able to flip the general public as shortly as doable towards Donald Trump.

And it doesn’t imply we don’t combat on different issues, however it means we put give attention to the central case that Donald Trump made to voters and the difficulty that voters care about probably the most, which is their financial well-being. And if we are able to shift public opinion towards Donald Trump as shortly as doable, it throws sand within the gears of Donald Trump’s authoritarian machine. As a result of proper now we do reside in a democracy.

Rosin: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

McBride: That’s in danger. However we do reside in a democracy. Public opinion nonetheless issues.

Rosin: I see. So am I studying between the traces right here to form of keep quieter on culture-war points? Like, Don’t combat these fights proper now. Don’t get into it. Don’t feed that fireside proper this minute.

McBride: I believe we’ve got to combat these fights in a wise manner. And we have to message in a better manner. Generally the message that’s viscerally comforting to somebody like me shouldn’t be useful, and typically even counterproductive, in reaching and convincing an individual who’s simply tuning into this dialog or who has a variety of thought.

We’ve to create area for some imperfect allies. We’ve to acknowledge that if we’re gonna have 50 % plus one in help of fundamental nondiscrimination protections, if we’re going to have 50 % plus one in help of defending entry to medically crucial care, that, by definition, must embrace some individuals within the 70 % who oppose trans individuals collaborating in sports activities. That dialog must proceed with individuals, however we are able to’t dismiss them as bigots or take away them from our coalition, as a result of then we could have a ceiling of 30 % on any coalition and protection of anybody’s rights.

Rosin: Okay. A last item: How have you ever discovered to navigate Congress? The incidents we talked about have been a few weeks in the past. I’m actually simply curious—are there locations you keep away from, individuals you don’t get within the elevator with? I’m really curious what your day-to-day life is.

McBride: My technique is to not let any of this get in the best way of me doing my job to the most effective of my capability.

Rosin: So that you simply, like, stroll to your workplace, use the toilet.

McBride: I don’t keep away from anybody. Properly, pay attention—I don’t give them alternatives to punish me as a result of I violate the rule that Johnson put in place. I exploit the restroom in my workplace.

Rosin: Which she knew you’d have.

McBride: Yeah. I don’t exit of my solution to worsen issues. However I simply do my job. In the event that they’re going to misgender me on the ground, look—loads of people, they’re like, Sarah doesn’t make a stink once we simply say, Member from Delaware, Consultant McBride. It’s a solution to respect Sarah. And it doesn’t make them really feel like they’re saying one thing that they don’t wish to say or that they really feel like they’d get politically punished by gendering me appropriately. Like, superb.

However there’s all the time a threat that somebody desires to make a factor out of it. I’m not going to not go to committee. I’m going to go, and I’m going to talk. I’m not going to not go to the ground. I’m going to go to the ground and converse. And I’m not going to allow them to derail that work as a result of they need quarter-hour of fame on social media.

I’m going to go within the elevator. I’ll say, Hello. If a few of these people cross me, I’ll say, Hey! How are you?

Rosin: In that folksy tone?

McBride: Completely.

Rosin: Uh-huh. (Laughs.)

McBride: How are ya?

Rosin: How are ya, sir? Oh, boy.

McBride: I’m not saying it’s the simplest factor, and I’m not saying I don’t get nervous, however, you already know, it’s what I’m there to do, and it’s what I signed up for.

[Music]

Rosin: Properly, thanks for coming immediately. Thanks for being sincere and in some way remaining idealistic. I admire it. (Laughs.)

McBride: All the time.

Rosin: Anyone’s gotta do it.

McBride: We’ve gotta have hope.

Rosin: Sure.

[Music]

Rosin: This episode of Radio Atlantic was produced by Jinae West and edited by Andrea Valdez. We had engineering help from Rob Smierciak, fact-checking by Sam Fentress. Claudine Ebeid is the manager producer of Atlantic audio, and Andrea Valdez is our managing editor.

Listeners, in case you like what you hear on Radio Atlantic, you possibly can help our work and the work of all Atlantic journalists once you subscribe to The Atlantic at theatlantic.com/podsub. That’s theatlantic.com/podsub.

I’m Hanna Rosin. Thanks for listening.